Best eyeliners in Canada

77 eyeliners ranked as of November 2, 2026. Each has an in-stock price in Canadian dollars from the maker’s own store or a retailer selling directly, checked within the last 30 days, and at least one accepted rating or published expert test with a score. 43 more are listed below with the reason they are not ranked.

Show Canadian-made eyeliners only

Not ranked: available, no rating or published test on record (3) · offer check lapsed (40)

1. 1

   e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

   e.l.f

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   99.89

   Availability and price (30%)

   100.00

   Total

   59.97

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.89 + 0.3 × 100.00 = 59.97

   • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 0/76) because 0 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $4.99 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   2. $5.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   3. $5.19 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 5 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

2. 2

   Wet N Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner

   Wet

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   99.95

   Availability and price (30%)

   96.84

   Total

   59.04

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.95 + 0.3 × 96.84 = 59.04

   • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 8/76) because 8 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $7.02 at Maguire Hair & Beauty Supplies (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Maguire Hair & Beauty Supplies Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

3. 3

   Essence Eyeliner Pen Extra Long-Lasting

   Essence

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   88.17

   Availability and price (30%)

   100.00

   Total

   56.45

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.17 + 0.3 × 100.00 = 56.45

   • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 531 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 0/76) because 0 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $4.99 at Pharmaprix.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Pharmaprix.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 4.4 out of 5 from 531 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

4. 4

   L'Oreal Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner

   L'Oreal Infallible

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   99.79

   Availability and price (30%)

   87.76

   Total

   56.27

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.79 + 0.3 × 87.76 = 56.27

   • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 31/76) because 31 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $19.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 5 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

5. 5

   E.l.f No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

   e.l.f

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   91.94

   Availability and price (30%)

   95.26

   Total

   56.16

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.94 + 0.3 × 95.26 = 56.16

   • Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 1,700 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 12/76) because 12 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $8.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   2. $8.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 4.6 out of 5 from 1,700 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

6. 6

   Annabelle Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

   Annabelle

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   89.51

   Availability and price (30%)

   97.24

   Total

   56.03

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.51 + 0.3 × 97.24 = 56.03

   • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 7 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 7/76) because 7 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $6.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 4.3 out of 5 from 7 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

7. 7

   e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner, Beige Flag

   e.l.f Tied rank

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   99.89

   Availability and price (30%)

   86.58

   Total

   55.94

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.89 + 0.3 × 86.58 = 55.94

   • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 4,500 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 34/76) because 34 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $20.97 at Herbkart.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Herbkart.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 5 out of 5 from 4,500 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

8. 7

   Heroine Make Kiss Me Smooth Liquid Eyeliner

   Heroine Tied rank

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   95.95

   Availability and price (30%)

   90.53

   Total

   55.94

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 95.95 + 0.3 × 90.53 = 55.94

   • Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 5,900 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 24/76) because 24 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $12.09 at Stylevana CA (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for Stylevana CA Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   2. $16.99 at konnichiwa.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for konnichiwa.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 4.8 out of 5 from 5,900 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

9. 9

   e.l.f. Cosmetics Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

   e.l.f

   Expert (40%)

   0.00 (No published expert test on file)

   Reviews (30%)

   88.02

   Availability and price (30%)

   98.42

   Total

   55.93

   0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.02 + 0.3 × 98.42 = 55.93

   • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
   • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 4/76) because 4 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

   1. $5.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

      See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

   Reviews by source

   • 4.4 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

   Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

10. 10

    e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    86.04

    Availability and price (30%)

    100.00

    Total

    55.81

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.04 + 0.3 × 100.00 = 55.81

    • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 0/76) because 0 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $4.99 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $5.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.3 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

11. 11

    Essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner Super Soft Gel-like Texture

    Essence

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.53

    Availability and price (30%)

    100.00

    Total

    55.36

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.53 + 0.3 × 100.00 = 55.36

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 511 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 0/76) because 0 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $4.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 511 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

12. 12

    Annabelle Retractable Eyeliner

    Annabelle

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    89.54

    Availability and price (30%)

    94.47

    Total

    55.20

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.54 + 0.3 × 94.47 = 55.20

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 15 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 14/76) because 14 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $8.99 at London Drugs (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for London Drugs Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 15 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

13. 13

    Rimmel London Wonder'Ink Precision Eyeliner Pen

    Rimmel London

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.72

    Availability and price (30%)

    91.71

    Total

    54.73

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.72 + 0.3 × 91.71 = 54.73

    • Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 28 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 21/76) because 21 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $11.49 at Pharmaprix.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Pharmaprix.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.6 out of 5 from 28 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

14. 14

    Maybelline Sculpting Stix 2-in-1 Eyeliner & Brush

    Maybelline

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    90.92

    Total

    54.28

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 90.92 = 54.28

    • Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 1,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 23/76) because 23 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $11.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.5 out of 5 from 1,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

15. 15

    Stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eye Liner

    Stila

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    99.57

    Availability and price (30%)

    81.05

    Total

    54.19

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.57 + 0.3 × 81.05 = 54.19

    • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 48/76) because 48 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $33.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $33.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

16. 16

    e.l.f H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.07

    Availability and price (30%)

    92.50

    Total

    54.17

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.07 + 0.3 × 92.50 = 54.17

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 1,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 19/76) because 19 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $10.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $10.00 at London Drugs (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for London Drugs Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 1,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

17. 17

    NYX Professional Makeup Epic Inky Stix Gel Eyeliner

    NYX Professional Makeup

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    91.94

    Availability and price (30%)

    88.55

    Total

    54.15

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.94 + 0.3 × 88.55 = 54.15

    • Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 1,500 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 29/76) because 29 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $18.49 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.6 out of 5 from 1,500 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

18. 18

    Marcelle 2-in-1 Retractable Eyeliner

    Marcelle

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    90.13

    Total

    54.04

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 90.13 = 54.04

    • Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 42 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 25/76) because 25 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $12.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.5 out of 5 from 42 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

19. 19

    e.l.f. Precision Liquid Eyeliner

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.16

    Availability and price (30%)

    95.26

    Total

    53.83

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.16 + 0.3 × 95.26 = 53.83

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 1,800 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 12/76) because 12 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $8.00 at e.l.f. Cosmetics (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for e.l.f. Cosmetics Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 1,800 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

20. 20

    Colorstay Eyeliner Revlon

    ColorStay

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    86.02

    Availability and price (30%)

    93.29

    Total

    53.79

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.02 + 0.3 × 93.29 = 53.79

    • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 17/76) because 17 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $9.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.3 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

21. 21

    Maybelline Line Express Sharpenable Wood Pencil Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Maybelline

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    82.28

    Availability and price (30%)

    96.05

    Total

    53.50

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 82.28 + 0.3 × 96.05 = 53.50

    • Reviews: 4.1 out of 5 from 1,400 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 10/76) because 10 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $7.99 at Familiprix (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Familiprix Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.1 out of 5 from 1,400 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

22. 22

    Milani Supreme Kohl Kajal Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Milani

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.20

    Availability and price (30%)

    89.74

    Total

    53.38

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.20 + 0.3 × 89.74 = 53.38

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 449 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 26/76) because 26 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $13.79 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 449 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

23. 23

    Maybelline Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Maybelline

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.02

    Availability and price (30%)

    93.29

    Total

    53.19

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.02 + 0.3 × 93.29 = 53.19

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 16,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 17/76) because 17 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $9.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 16,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

24. 24

    L'Oreal Paris Liquid Eyeliner Infallible Super Slim (no separate page yet)

    L'Oréal Paris

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.10

    Availability and price (30%)

    92.11

    Total

    52.86

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.10 + 0.3 × 92.11 = 52.86

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 3,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 20/76) because 20 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $10.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 3,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

25. 25

    Essence Satin Blend Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Essence

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    77.48

    Availability and price (30%)

    98.03

    Total

    52.65

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 77.48 + 0.3 × 98.03 = 52.65

    • Reviews: 3.8 out of 5 from 423 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 5/76) because 5 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $5.99 at Pharmaprix.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Pharmaprix.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $5.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.8 out of 5 from 423 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

26. 26

    Kaleidos Epiphany Glow Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Kaleidos

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.33

    Availability and price (30%)

    84.61

    Total

    52.48

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.33 + 0.3 × 84.61 = 52.48

    • Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 10 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 39/76) because 39 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $22.37 at Kaleidos Makeup (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Kaleidos Makeup Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.6 out of 5 from 10 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

27. 27

    VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil (no separate page yet)

    VASANTI

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    86.05

    Availability and price (30%)

    88.16

    Total

    52.26

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.05 + 0.3 × 88.16 = 52.26

    • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 3,800 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 30/76) because 30 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $19.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.3 out of 5 from 3,800 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

28. 28

    SEPHORA COLLECTION 12H Colourful Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner Duo Set (no separate page yet)

    SEPHORA COLLECTION

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.74

    Availability and price (30%)

    83.42

    Total

    52.25

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.74 + 0.3 × 83.42 = 52.25

    • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 4 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 42/76) because 42 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $27.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 4 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

29. 29

    L'Or al Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner Black Brown 0.008 oz. Black Brown 1 Count (Pack of 1) (no separate page yet)

    L'Or

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    99.79

    Availability and price (30%)

    74.34

    Total

    52.24

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.79 + 0.3 × 74.34 = 52.24

    • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 65/76) because 65 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $48.91 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

30. 30

    Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (no separate page yet)

    Stila

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    82.63

    Total

    51.79

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 82.63 = 51.79

    • Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 42,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 44/76) because 44 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $29.00 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $69.88 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.5 out of 5 from 42,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

31. 31

    Annabelle Vegan Kohl Eyeliner Matte Finish 111 Olive Green Intense Colour Payoff Long-Lasting Cruelty-Free Paraben-Free Silicone-Free Fragrance-Free (no separate page yet)

    Annabelle

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    89.29

    Availability and price (30%)

    83.03

    Total

    51.70

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.29 + 0.3 × 83.03 = 51.70

    • Reviews: 2.7 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 43/76) because 43 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $27.94 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.7 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

32. 32

    Marcelle Forever Sharp Kohl Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Marcelle

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    82.33

    Availability and price (30%)

    89.34

    Total

    51.50

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 82.33 + 0.3 × 89.34 = 51.50

    • Reviews: 2.2 out of 5 from 10 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 27/76) because 27 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $14.39 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.2 out of 5 from 10 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

33. 33

    Sephora Collection Intense Felt-Tip Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    SEPHORA COLLECTION

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.19

    Availability and price (30%)

    87.37

    Total

    51.47

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.19 + 0.3 × 87.37 = 51.47

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 1,500 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 32/76) because 32 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $20.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 1,500 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

34. 34

    ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil, Black [201], 0.01 oz (Pack of 4) (no separate page yet)

    ColorStay Tied rank

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    99.88

    Availability and price (30%)

    71.58

    Total

    51.44

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.88 + 0.3 × 71.58 = 51.44

    • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 4,200 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 72/76) because 72 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $68.90 at Desertcart.ae (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Desertcart.ae Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 4,200 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

35. 34

    Lancôme Le Stylo Waterproof Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Lancôme Tied rank

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    81.45

    Total

    51.44

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 81.45 = 51.44

    • Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 6,500 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 47/76) because 47 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $31.84 at Loja Glamourosa (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Loja Glamourosa Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $43.00 at London Drugs (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for London Drugs Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.5 out of 5 from 6,500 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

36. 36

    Florence by Mills What's My Line? Longwear Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Florence

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    85.09

    Availability and price (30%)

    85.79

    Total

    51.26

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 85.09 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 51.26

    • Reviews: 3.8 out of 5 from 27 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 36/76) because 36 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $21.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.8 out of 5 from 27 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

37. 37

    Charlotte Tilbury Eyeliner Pencil Walk Of No Shame (no separate page yet)

    Charlotte Tilbury

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    93.48

    Availability and price (30%)

    77.11

    Total

    51.18

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.48 + 0.3 × 77.11 = 51.18

    • Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 338 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 58/76) because 58 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $39.50 at Charlotte Tilbury (maker's own store, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Charlotte Tilbury Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.7 out of 5 from 338 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

38. 38

    Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil Black 201 0.01 oz (Pack of 4) Black 201 (no separate page yet)

    Revlon

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    99.88

    Availability and price (30%)

    70.39

    Total

    51.08

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 99.88 + 0.3 × 70.39 = 51.08

    • Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 4,200 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 75/76) because 75 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $118.79 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 4,200 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

39. 39

    Florence By Mills What's My Line? Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Florence

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.31

    Availability and price (30%)

    85.79

    Total

    51.03

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.31 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 51.03

    • Reviews: 4.1 out of 5 from 123 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 36/76) because 36 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $21.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.1 out of 5 from 123 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

40. 40

    Almay Intense Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Almay

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    78.52

    Availability and price (30%)

    91.32

    Total

    50.95

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 78.52 + 0.3 × 91.32 = 50.95

    • Reviews: 3.9 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 22/76) because 22 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $11.79 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.9 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

41. 41

    e.l.f Intense Ink Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    e.l.f Tied rank

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    74.18

    Availability and price (30%)

    94.47

    Total

    50.60

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 74.18 + 0.3 × 94.47 = 50.60

    • Reviews: 3.7 out of 5 from 4,500 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 14/76) because 14 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $8.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.7 out of 5 from 4,500 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

42. 41

    e.l.f. Cosmetics Smoky Kohl Eyeliner - Rare Emerald (no separate page yet)

    e.l.f Tied rank

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    82.09

    Availability and price (30%)

    86.58

    Total

    50.60

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 82.09 + 0.3 × 86.58 = 50.60

    • Reviews: 4.1 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 34/76) because 34 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $20.97 at Herbkart.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Herbkart.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.1 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

43. 43

    about-face Line Artist Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    about-face

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    81.87

    Availability and price (30%)

    85.79

    Total

    50.30

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 81.87 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 50.30

    • Reviews: 4 out of 5 from 218 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 36/76) because 36 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $21.00 at Pharmaprix.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Pharmaprix.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $21.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4 out of 5 from 218 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

44. 44

    MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner (no separate page yet)

    Mac

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.02

    Availability and price (30%)

    79.47

    Total

    50.25

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.02 + 0.3 × 79.47 = 50.25

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 4,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 52/76) because 52 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $35.00 at MAC Cosmetics CA (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for MAC Cosmetics CA Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $35.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 4,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

45. 45

    Fenty Beauty Fine Linez Precision Gel Eyeliner Pencil (no separate page yet)

    Fenty

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.11

    Availability and price (30%)

    79.08

    Total

    50.16

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.11 + 0.3 × 79.08 = 50.16

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 887 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 53/76) because 53 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $35.50 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 887 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

46. 46

    Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Bobbi

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    90.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    76.71

    Total

    50.01

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 76.71 = 50.01

    • Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 16,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 59/76) because 59 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $39.61 at PerfumesClub.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for PerfumesClub.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.5 out of 5 from 16,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

47. 47

    Milk Makeup Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner 0.012 fl oz Twist-Up Design (no separate page yet)

    Milk

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.53

    Availability and price (30%)

    81.84

    Total

    49.91

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.53 + 0.3 × 81.84 = 49.91

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 511 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 46/76) because 46 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $30.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 511 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

48. 48

    Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Wet

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    70.29

    Availability and price (30%)

    96.05

    Total

    49.90

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 70.29 + 0.3 × 96.05 = 49.90

    • Reviews: 3.5 out of 5 from 3,400 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 10/76) because 10 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $7.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.5 out of 5 from 3,400 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

49. 49

    Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Milani

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    76.83

    Availability and price (30%)

    88.95

    Total

    49.73

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 76.83 + 0.3 × 88.95 = 49.73

    • Reviews: 3.7 out of 5 from 233 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 28/76) because 28 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $17.39 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.7 out of 5 from 233 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

50. 50

    Marc Jacobs Beauty Drawn This Way Long-Wear Waterproof Sharpenable Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Marc

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.60

    Availability and price (30%)

    80.66

    Total

    49.58

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.60 + 0.3 × 80.66 = 49.58

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 454 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 49/76) because 49 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $34.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 454 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

51. 51

    Clinique High Impact Gel Tech Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Clinique

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    86.10

    Availability and price (30%)

    78.68

    Total

    49.43

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.10 + 0.3 × 78.68 = 49.43

    • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 1,900 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 54/76) because 54 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $36.00 at Clinique CA (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Clinique CA Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $36.00 at London Drugs (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for London Drugs Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.3 out of 5 from 1,900 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

52. 52

    Benefit Roller Liner Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Benefit

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.04

    Availability and price (30%)

    80.66

    Total

    49.41

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.04 + 0.3 × 80.66 = 49.41

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 7,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 49/76) because 49 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $34.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 7,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

53. 53

    Wonderskin 1440 Longwear Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Wonderskin

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    80.02

    Availability and price (30%)

    84.21

    Total

    49.27

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 80.02 + 0.3 × 84.21 = 49.27

    • Reviews: 4 out of 5 from 30,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 40/76) because 40 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $23.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $25.21 at REVOLVE (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for REVOLVE Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4 out of 5 from 30,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

54. 54

    Jones Road Beauty Gel Liner Richly Pigmented Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Jones

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.04

    Availability and price (30%)

    74.74

    Total

    48.83

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.04 + 0.3 × 74.74 = 48.83

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 64/76) because 64 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $46.00 at Jones Road (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Jones Road Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 2,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

55. 55

    Dior Diorshow On Stage Crayon Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil (no separate page yet)

    Dior

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.06

    Availability and price (30%)

    73.95

    Total

    48.60

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.06 + 0.3 × 73.95 = 48.60

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 1,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 66/76) because 66 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $49.00 at DIOR (maker's own store, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for DIOR Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 1,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

56. 56

    Too Faced Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Too

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    84.06

    Availability and price (30%)

    77.89

    Total

    48.59

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.06 + 0.3 × 77.89 = 48.59

    • Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 4,900 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 56/76) because 56 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $37.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.2 out of 5 from 4,900 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

57. 57

    Satin Kajal Liner in Fig | Longwear Waterproof Matte Deep Purple Eyeliner - Victoria Beckham Beauty (no separate page yet)

    Satin

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    88.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    72.76

    Total

    48.23

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.00 + 0.3 × 72.76 = 48.23

    • Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 80,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 69/76) because 69 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $50.00 at Victoria Beckham Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Victoria Beckham Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.4 out of 5 from 80,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

58. 58

    Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Bobbi

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    86.08

    Availability and price (30%)

    73.95

    Total

    48.01

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.08 + 0.3 × 73.95 = 48.01

    • Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 2,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 66/76) because 66 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $49.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.3 out of 5 from 2,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

59. 59

    e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner Eye Pencil - 1 gm Berry Necessary (no separate page yet)

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    74.17

    Availability and price (30%)

    83.82

    Total

    47.40

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 74.17 + 0.3 × 83.82 = 47.40

    • Reviews: 3.7 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 41/76) because 41 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $25.00 at Swadesii (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Swadesii Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.7 out of 5 from 4,600 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

60. 60

    ILIA Thru Line Waterproof Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    ILIA Thru Line

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    78.52

    Availability and price (30%)

    78.68

    Total

    47.16

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 78.52 + 0.3 × 78.68 = 47.16

    • Reviews: 3.9 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 54/76) because 54 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $36.00 at ILIA Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for ILIA Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.9 out of 5 from 1,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

61. 61

    e.l.f. Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen Black (no separate page yet)

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    76.56

    Availability and price (30%)

    75.92

    Total

    45.74

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 76.56 + 0.3 × 75.92 = 45.74

    • Reviews: 3.8 out of 5 from 1,200 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 61/76) because 61 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $41.92 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.8 out of 5 from 1,200 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

62. 62

    ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil, Black [201], 0.01 oz (Pack of 6) (no separate page yet)

    ColorStay

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    76.16

    Availability and price (30%)

    70.00

    Total

    43.85

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 76.16 + 0.3 × 70.00 = 43.85

    • Reviews: 3.8 out of 5 from 4,300 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 76/76) because 76 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $133.96 at Desertcart.ae (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Desertcart.ae Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.8 out of 5 from 4,300 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

63. 63

    L'Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    L'Oréal Paris

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    50.62

    Availability and price (30%)

    94.47

    Total

    43.53

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 50.62 + 0.3 × 94.47 = 43.53

    • Reviews: 2.5 out of 5 from 3,200 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 14/76) because 14 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $8.99 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.5 out of 5 from 3,200 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

64. 64

    SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    SEPHORA COLLECTION

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    56.22

    Availability and price (30%)

    87.37

    Total

    43.08

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 56.22 + 0.3 × 87.37 = 43.08

    • Reviews: 2.8 out of 5 from 7,700 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 32/76) because 32 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $20.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.8 out of 5 from 7,700 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

65. 65

    L'Or al Paris Cosmetics Makeup Infallible Pro-last Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof & Smudge-resistant Glides On Easily To Create Any Look Black shimmer (no separate page yet)

    L'Or

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    66.39

    Availability and price (30%)

    75.92

    Total

    42.69

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 66.39 + 0.3 × 75.92 = 42.69

    • Reviews: 3.3 out of 5 from 3,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 61/76) because 61 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $41.92 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.3 out of 5 from 3,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

66. 66

    Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil Charcoal 204 0.01 oz (Pack of 3) (no separate page yet)

    Revlon

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    70.09

    Availability and price (30%)

    71.18

    Total

    42.38

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 70.09 + 0.3 × 71.18 = 42.38

    • Reviews: 3.5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 73/76) because 73 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $83.85 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

67. 67

    e.l.f. Cosmetics Intense Ink Eyeliner Blackest Black (no separate page yet)

    e.l.f

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    64.29

    Availability and price (30%)

    75.92

    Total

    42.06

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 64.29 + 0.3 × 75.92 = 42.06

    • Reviews: 3.2 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 61/76) because 61 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $41.92 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.2 out of 5 from 4,400 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

68. 68

    Annabelle Waterline Matte Kohl Eyeliner Pencil (no separate page yet)

    Annabelle

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    57.38

    Availability and price (30%)

    79.87

    Total

    41.18

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 57.38 + 0.3 × 79.87 = 41.18

    • Reviews: 2.1 out of 5 from 106 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 51/76) because 51 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $34.92 at Snapklik.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Snapklik.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.1 out of 5 from 106 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

69. 69

    LAURA GELLER Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner Pencil (no separate page yet)

    Laura

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    58.26

    Availability and price (30%)

    77.89

    Total

    40.85

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 58.26 + 0.3 × 77.89 = 40.85

    • Reviews: 2.9 out of 5 from 6,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 56/76) because 56 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $37.00 at Laura Geller (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Laura Geller Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.9 out of 5 from 6,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

70. 70

    Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Perfect Strokes Longwear & Waterproof Gel Eyeliner True (no separate page yet)

    Rare Beauty

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    53.03

    Availability and price (30%)

    82.63

    Total

    40.70

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 53.03 + 0.3 × 82.63 = 40.70

    • Reviews: 2.6 out of 5 from 1,800 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 44/76) because 44 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $29.00 at Sephora (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Sephora Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.6 out of 5 from 1,800 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

71. 71

    Dior Diorshow Stylo Waterproof Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    Dior

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    61.67

    Availability and price (30%)

    73.95

    Total

    40.69

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 61.67 + 0.3 × 73.95 = 40.69

    • Reviews: 3 out of 5 from 850 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 66/76) because 66 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $49.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Shoppers Drug Mart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $49.00 at DIOR (maker's own store, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for DIOR Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3 out of 5 from 850 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

72. 72

    L'Oreal Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner Nude 0.042 Ounce (1 Count) 1 Count (Pack of 1) Nude (no separate page yet)

    L'Oreal Infallible

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    62.47

    Availability and price (30%)

    72.37

    Total

    40.45

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 62.47 + 0.3 × 72.37 = 40.45

    • Reviews: 3.1 out of 5 from 2,900 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 70/76) because 70 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $55.90 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 3.1 out of 5 from 2,900 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

73. 73

    L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant Glides on Easily to Create any Look Burgundy 0.042 Oz. (Pack (no separate page yet)

    L'Oréal Paris

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    58.54

    Availability and price (30%)

    72.37

    Total

    39.27

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 58.54 + 0.3 × 72.37 = 39.27

    • Reviews: 2.9 out of 5 from 2,900 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 70/76) because 70 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $55.90 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 2.9 out of 5 from 2,900 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). Used in the review component.

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

74. 74

    BBIA Last Auto Gel Eyeliner (no separate page yet)

    BBIA

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    0.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    97.63

    Total

    29.29

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 97.63 = 29.29

    • Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 6/76) because 6 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $6.43 at YesStyle.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for YesStyle.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    2. $7.19 at Stylevana CA (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Stylevana CA Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.8 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

75. 75

    BBIA - Last Auto Gel Eyeliner - 0.3g - 22 Peach Pastel (no separate page yet)

    BBIA

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    0.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    96.45

    Total

    28.94

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 96.45 = 28.94

    • Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 9/76) because 9 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $7.19 at Stylevana CA (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 2, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Stylevana CA Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 4.8 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 2, 2026 (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

76. 76

    Revlon Colorstay Eye Liner Pencil, Black Violet 209 (no separate page yet)

    Revlon

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    0.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    76.32

    Total

    22.90

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 76.32 = 22.90

    • Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 60/76) because 60 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $40.34 at Desertcart.ae (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for Desertcart.ae Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.

77. 77

    Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Topez/208 0.01 Ounce (no separate page yet)

    Revlon

    Expert (40%)

    0.00 (No published expert test on file)

    Reviews (30%)

    0.00

    Availability and price (30%)

    70.79

    Total

    21.24

    0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 70.79 = 21.24

    • Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
    • Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 74/76) because 74 of the 76 other ranked eyeliners have a lower lowest price.

    1. $90.83 at GoSupps Beauty (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on November 1, 2026.

       See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps Beauty Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.

    Reviews by source

    • 5 out of 5 from 11,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved November 1, 2026 (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)

    Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.