Best creamy peanut butters in Canada
58 creamy peanut butters ranked as of . Each has an in-stock price in Canadian dollars from the maker’s own store or a retailer selling directly, checked within the last 30 days, and at least one accepted rating or published expert test with a score. 97 more are listed below with the reason they are not ranked.
Show Canadian-made creamy peanut butters only
Not ranked: available, no rating or published test on record (57) · offer check lapsed (40)
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 95.21
- Availability and price (30%)
- 100.00
- Total
- 58.56
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 95.21 + 0.3 × 100.00 = 58.56
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 332 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 0/57) because 0 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$4.53 at prozis.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for prozis.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 332 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 96.12
- Availability and price (30%)
- 97.89
- Total
- 58.20
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 96.12 + 0.3 × 97.89 = 58.20
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 79 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 4/57) because 4 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$4.99 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 79 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 92.20
- Availability and price (30%)
- 99.47
- Total
- 57.50
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 92.20 + 0.3 × 99.47 = 57.50
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 29 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 1/57) because 1 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$4.97 at superc.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for superc.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$7.49 at foodbasics.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for foodbasics.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 29 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.71
- Availability and price (30%)
- 99.47
- Total
- 57.35
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.71 + 0.3 × 99.47 = 57.35
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 293 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 1/57) because 1 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$4.97 at superc.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for superc.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 293 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.62
- Availability and price (30%)
- 99.47
- Total
- 57.33
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.62 + 0.3 × 99.47 = 57.33
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 212 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 1/57) because 1 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$4.97 at superc.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for superc.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 212 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 92.61
- Availability and price (30%)
- 96.32
- Total
- 56.68
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 92.61 + 0.3 × 96.32 = 56.68
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 94 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 7/57) because 7 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.29 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 94 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.49
- Availability and price (30%)
- 95.26
- Total
- 56.63
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.49 + 0.3 × 95.26 = 56.63
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 341 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 9/57) because 9 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.49 at Uncle Wiener's Wholesale (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Uncle Wiener's Wholesale Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$14.99 at Jubilee Junction (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Jubilee Junction Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 341 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.38
- Availability and price (30%)
- 96.84
- Total
- 56.47
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.38 + 0.3 × 96.84 = 56.47
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 8 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 6/57) because 6 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.04 at prozis.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for prozis.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 8 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.57
- Availability and price (30%)
- 97.37
- Total
- 56.38
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.57 + 0.3 × 97.37 = 56.38
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 5/57) because 5 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$5.99 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 97.35
- Availability and price (30%)
- 89.47
- Total
- 56.05
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 97.35 + 0.3 × 89.47 = 56.05
- Reviews: 4.9 out of 5 from 569 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 20/57) because 20 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$8.99 at Snackamarack (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Snackamarack Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.9 out of 5 from 569 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.78
- Availability and price (30%)
- 93.68
- Total
- 55.64
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.78 + 0.3 × 93.68 = 55.64
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 397 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 12/57) because 12 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.99 at Greens Market (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Greens Market Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 397 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 89.19
- Availability and price (30%)
- 95.79
- Total
- 55.49
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.19 + 0.3 × 95.79 = 55.49
- Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 34 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 8/57) because 8 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.45 at A.Vogel Canada (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for A.Vogel Canada Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$6.49 at Aubut (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Aubut Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$7.49 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.4 out of 5 from 34 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.98
- Availability and price (30%)
- 92.11
- Total
- 55.23
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.98 + 0.3 × 92.11 = 55.23
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 5,100 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 15/57) because 15 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.49 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 5,100 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.37
- Availability and price (30%)
- 92.63
- Total
- 55.20
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.37 + 0.3 × 92.63 = 55.20
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 26 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 14/57) because 14 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.14 at Naturitas (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Naturitas Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 26 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 89.20
- Availability and price (30%)
- 94.74
- Total
- 55.18
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.20 + 0.3 × 94.74 = 55.18
- Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 33 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 10/57) because 10 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.87 at ubereats.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for ubereats.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$9.99 at Maker House Co (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Maker House Co Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.4 out of 5 from 33 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 97.58
- Availability and price (30%)
- 86.32
- Total
- 55.17
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 97.58 + 0.3 × 86.32 = 55.17
- Reviews: 4.9 out of 5 from 895 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 26/57) because 26 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.68 at prozis.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for prozis.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.9 out of 5 from 895 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.77
- Availability and price (30%)
- 92.11
- Total
- 55.16
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.77 + 0.3 × 92.11 = 55.16
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 21 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 15/57) because 15 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.49 at Well.ca (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Well.ca Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$8.29 at Avril Supermarché Santé (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Avril Supermarché Santé Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 21 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 88.92
- Availability and price (30%)
- 94.21
- Total
- 54.94
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.92 + 0.3 × 94.21 = 54.94
- Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 59 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 11/57) because 11 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.98 at ubereats.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for ubereats.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.4 out of 5 from 59 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.54
- Availability and price (30%)
- 89.47
- Total
- 54.90
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.54 + 0.3 × 89.47 = 54.90
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 384 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 20/57) because 20 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$8.99 at London Drugs (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for London Drugs Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$10.79 at Save-On-Foods (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Save-On-Foods Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 384 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 92.25
- Availability and price (30%)
- 90.53
- Total
- 54.83
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 92.25 + 0.3 × 90.53 = 54.83
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 30 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 18/57) because 18 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.99 at Save-On-Foods (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Save-On-Foods Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 30 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
21
Maranatha Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Maranatha
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.13
- Availability and price (30%)
- 89.47
- Total
- 54.78
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.13 + 0.3 × 89.47 = 54.78
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 179 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 20/57) because 20 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$8.99 at Save-On-Foods (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Save-On-Foods Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 179 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
22
Planters Smooth Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Planters
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.23
- Availability and price (30%)
- 92.11
- Total
- 54.70
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.23 + 0.3 × 92.11 = 54.70
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 15/57) because 15 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.49 at Khorak Supermarket (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Khorak Supermarket Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$9.00 at Aurora Importing (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Aurora Importing Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
23
Pic's Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Pic's
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.76
- Availability and price (30%)
- 87.37
- Total
- 54.34
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.76 + 0.3 × 87.37 = 54.34
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 779 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 24/57) because 24 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.07 at ShopNZ.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for ShopNZ.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 779 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
24
Fatso Maple Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Fatso
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 90.53
- Total
- 54.16
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 90.53 = 54.16
- Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 75 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 18/57) because 18 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$7.99 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Also listed for this product:
- Fatso (maker's own store): offer never checked.
Reviews by source
- 4.5 out of 5 from 75 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
25
Urban Platter Creamy Peanut Butter, 250g (Classic Smooth | Single Ingredient | Keto-Friendly) (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.23
- Availability and price (30%)
- 89.47
- Total
- 53.91
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.23 + 0.3 × 89.47 = 53.91
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 20/57) because 20 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$8.99 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
26
Nuts To You Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 96.33
- Availability and price (30%)
- 83.16
- Total
- 53.85
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 96.33 + 0.3 × 83.16 = 53.85
- Reviews: 4.9 out of 5 from 190 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 32/57) because 32 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$12.49 at La Boite à Grains (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for La Boite à Grains Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.9 out of 5 from 190 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
27
Nutella Peanut Spread With Cocoa, Smooth and Creamy (no separate page yet)
Nutella
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 85.03
- Availability and price (30%)
- 93.68
- Total
- 53.61
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 85.03 + 0.3 × 93.68 = 53.61
- Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 241 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 12/57) because 12 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$6.99 at Voilà by Sobeys (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Voilà by Sobeys Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.2 out of 5 from 241 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
28
Mumgry Smooth Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Mumgry
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.83
- Availability and price (30%)
- 85.79
- Total
- 52.99
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.83 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 52.99
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 8 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 27/57) because 27 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.99 at Healthy Planet (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Healthy Planet Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 8 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
29
Nuts.com Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Nuts.com
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 95.32
- Availability and price (30%)
- 81.05
- Total
- 52.91
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 95.32 + 0.3 × 81.05 = 52.91
- Reviews: 4.9 out of 5 from 99 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 36/57) because 36 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$13.97 at Nuts.com (maker's own store, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Nuts.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.9 out of 5 from 99 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
30
Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Spread
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 95.76
- Availability and price (30%)
- 79.47
- Total
- 52.57
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 95.76 + 0.3 × 79.47 = 52.57
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 1,200 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 39/57) because 39 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$20.48 at iHerb (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for iHerb Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 1,200 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
31
Once Again Creamy Peanut Butter Unsweetened (no separate page yet)
Once Again
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 94.22
- Availability and price (30%)
- 80.53
- Total
- 52.43
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 94.22 + 0.3 × 80.53 = 52.43
- Reviews: 4.8 out of 5 from 119 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 37/57) because 37 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$16.51 at Country Life Natural Foods (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Country Life Natural Foods Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.8 out of 5 from 119 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
32
Pintola All Natural Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Pintola All Natural
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 88.56
- Availability and price (30%)
- 85.79
- Total
- 52.31
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.56 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 52.31
- Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 28 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 27/57) because 27 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.99 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.3 out of 5 from 28 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
33
Justin's 16 oz Honey Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Justin's
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 83.68
- Total
- 52.10
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 83.68 = 52.10
- Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 378 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 31/57) because 31 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$10.99 at Nature Sante (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Nature Sante Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.5 out of 5 from 378 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
34
Spread The Love NAKED CRUNCH Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Spread
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.80
- Availability and price (30%)
- 79.47
- Total
- 51.98
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.80 + 0.3 × 79.47 = 51.98
- Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 from 930 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 39/57) because 39 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$20.48 at iHerb (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for iHerb Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 930 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
35
Cocomo Coconut Peanut Butter with MCT Oil 10 oz No Seed Oils (no separate page yet)
Cocomo
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 93.06
- Availability and price (30%)
- 80.00
- Total
- 51.92
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 93.06 + 0.3 × 80.00 = 51.92
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 22 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 38/57) because 38 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$16.99 at Natura Market (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Natura Market Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 22 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
36
Biona Peanut Butter Smooth Unsalted 250 g (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 88.56
- Availability and price (30%)
- 84.21
- Total
- 51.83
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.56 + 0.3 × 84.21 = 51.83
- Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 127 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 30/57) because 30 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$10.05 at Cremashop.eu (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Cremashop.eu Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.4 out of 5 from 127 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
37
Once Again Natural Old Fashioned No Salt Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Once Again
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 89.75
- Availability and price (30%)
- 82.63
- Total
- 51.71
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 89.75 + 0.3 × 82.63 = 51.71
- Reviews: 4.4 out of 5 from 7 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 33/57) because 33 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$12.82 at Country Life Natural Foods (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Country Life Natural Foods Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.4 out of 5 from 7 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
38
Mumgry Chocolate Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Mumgry
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.73
- Availability and price (30%)
- 81.58
- Total
- 51.69
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.73 + 0.3 × 81.58 = 51.69
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 29 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 35/57) because 35 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$12.99 at Vegan Supply (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Vegan Supply Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 29 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
39
Justin's Peanut Butter Classic (no separate page yet)
Justin's
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 82.11
- Total
- 51.63
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.00 + 0.3 × 82.11 = 51.63
- Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 from 626 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 34/57) because 34 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$12.95 at iHerb (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for iHerb Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.5 out of 5 from 626 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
40
Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Reese's
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 84.29
- Availability and price (30%)
- 85.79
- Total
- 51.02
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.29 + 0.3 × 85.79 = 51.02
- Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 1,000 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 27/57) because 27 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.99 at So Sweet Canada (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for So Sweet Canada Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$21.69 at Desertcart.ae (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Desertcart.ae Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$48.90 at GoSupps.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$85.99 at desertcart.com.sa (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for desertcart.com.sa Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.2 out of 5 from 1,000 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
41
Meridian Peanut Butter Smooth (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.15
- Availability and price (30%)
- 76.32
- Total
- 50.24
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.15 + 0.3 × 76.32 = 50.24
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 68 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 45/57) because 45 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$24.90 at McGrocer (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for McGrocer Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 68 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
42
Kraft Peanut Butter Natural Smooth 750g (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 91.62
- Availability and price (30%)
- 75.79
- Total
- 50.22
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 91.62 + 0.3 × 75.79 = 50.22
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 212 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 46/57) because 46 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$25.14 at Pantry Canada (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Pantry Canada Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 212 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
43
RiteBite Max Protein Choco Creamy Peanut Butter Spread (no separate page yet)
RiteBite Max Protein
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.57
- Availability and price (30%)
- 73.68
- Total
- 49.28
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.57 + 0.3 × 73.68 = 49.28
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 50/57) because 50 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$32.39 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
44
Pintola HIGH Protein Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Pintola High Protein
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.41
- Availability and price (30%)
- 73.16
- Total
- 49.07
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.41 + 0.3 × 73.16 = 49.07
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 51/57) because 51 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$37.77 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
45
Whole Earth Organic Smooth Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
Whole
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 84.90
- Availability and price (30%)
- 78.42
- Total
- 49.00
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 84.90 + 0.3 × 78.42 = 49.00
- Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 285 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 41/57) because 41 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$20.58 at BritishCornerShop.co.uk (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for BritishCornerShop.co.uk Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.2 out of 5 from 285 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
46
Meridian Organic Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 85.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 77.89
- Total
- 48.87
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 85.00 + 0.3 × 77.89 = 48.87
- Reviews: 4.2 out of 5 from 249 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 42/57) because 42 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$21.72 at BritishCornerShop.co.uk (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for BritishCornerShop.co.uk Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.2 out of 5 from 249 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
47
Tropical Sun Smooth Peanut Butter - Rich & Creamy | 340g (Pack of 3) (no separate page yet)
Tropical
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 88.85
- Availability and price (30%)
- 72.63
- Total
- 48.44
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.85 + 0.3 × 72.63 = 48.44
- Reviews: 3 out of 5 from 2 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 52/57) because 52 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$40.00 at Kettleworth's (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Kettleworth's Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 3 out of 5 from 2 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
48
Pintola All Natural Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet)
Pintola All Natural
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.20
- Availability and price (30%)
- 71.05
- Total
- 48.38
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.20 + 0.3 × 71.05 = 48.38
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 55/57) because 55 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$169.01 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
49
Pintola High Protein Creamy Peanut Butter with Organic Jaggery - 1 kg / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet)
Pintola High Protein
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.41
- Availability and price (30%)
- 70.53
- Total
- 48.28
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.41 + 0.3 × 70.53 = 48.28
- Reviews: 4.6 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 56/57) because 56 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$175.52 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.6 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
50
Pintola Dark Chocolate Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet)
Pintola
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 88.86
- Availability and price (30%)
- 71.58
- Total
- 48.13
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 88.86 + 0.3 × 71.58 = 48.13
- Reviews: 4.3 out of 5 from 20 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 54/57) because 54 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$168.18 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.3 out of 5 from 20 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
51
Pintola Classic Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet)
Pintola
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 90.20
- Availability and price (30%)
- 70.00
- Total
- 48.06
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 90.20 + 0.3 × 70.00 = 48.06
- Reviews: 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 57/57) because 57 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$257.74 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
52
Peter Pan, Honey Roasted Creamy Peanut Butter, 16.3oz Jar (Pack of 4), Multicolor (no separate page yet)
Peter Pan
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 86.04
- Availability and price (30%)
- 72.11
- Total
- 47.45
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 86.04 + 0.3 × 72.11 = 47.45
- Reviews: 4.1 out of 5 from 49 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 53/57) because 53 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$41.92 at GoSupps.com (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for GoSupps.com Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.1 out of 5 from 49 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
53
Pintola Organic Unsweetened Peanut Butter Creamy 1kg High Protein 30g & 9g Dietary Fiber (no separate page yet)
Pintola
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 81.75
- Availability and price (30%)
- 74.74
- Total
- 46.95
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 81.75 + 0.3 × 74.74 = 46.95
- Reviews: 2.5 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 48/57) because 48 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$28.49 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
$60.41 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 2.5 out of 5 from 13 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
54
Pintola All Natural Peanut Butter Crunchy Unsweetened 30g Protein (no separate page yet)
Pintola All Natural
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 74.84
- Availability and price (30%)
- 77.37
- Total
- 45.66
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 74.84 + 0.3 × 77.37 = 45.66
- Reviews: 3.1 out of 5 from 59 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 43/57) because 43 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$22.39 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 3.1 out of 5 from 59 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
55
Dr. Oetker FunFoods Peanut Butter Creamy 375g 91% Roasted Peanuts 26% Protein per 100g (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 62.17
- Availability and price (30%)
- 86.84
- Total
- 44.70
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 62.17 + 0.3 × 86.84 = 44.70
- Reviews: 2.1 out of 5 from 69 reviews on Google Shopping, adjusted toward 4.5 as if it started with 50 reviews.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 25/57) because 25 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$9.49 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 2.1 out of 5 from 69 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). Used in the review component.
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
56
Pintola Original Classic Peanut Butter Creamy 350g with High Protein 26g & 7.2g Fiber (no separate page yet)
Pintola
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 0.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 77.37
- Total
- 23.21
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 77.37 = 23.21
- Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 43/57) because 43 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$22.39 at Distacart (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Distacart Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
57
Pintola Classic Peanut Butter Original American Recipe With High Protein 26g & 7.2g Fiber (no separate page yet)
Pintola
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 0.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 75.26
- Total
- 22.58
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 75.26 = 22.58
- Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 47/57) because 47 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$25.49 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 5 out of 5 from 1 review on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
-
58
Natural Peanut Butter (no separate page yet)
- Expert (40%)
- 0.00 (No published expert test on file)
- Reviews (30%)
- 0.00
- Availability and price (30%)
- 74.21
- Total
- 22.26
0.4 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 0.00 + 0.3 × 74.21 = 22.26
- Reviews: no accepted review source with a rating and a count outside store-wide totals, so 0.
- Availability and price: 70 for the fresh in-stock offer, plus 30 × (1 − 49/57) because 49 of the 57 other ranked creamy peanut butters have a lower lowest price.
$28.99 at Silkrute (retailer selling directly, listed on Google Shopping), in stock when checked on .
See the Google Shopping listing for Silkrute Affiliate link. We may earn a commission. Rank and inclusion are never affected.
Reviews by source
- 4.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews on Google Shopping, retrieved (source). (store-wide total, not used for ranking)
Each source’s rating is shown on its own. Ratings from different sources are never combined.
Available in Canada, not ranked: no rating or published test on record
A first-party Canadian seller has these in stock at a price in Canadian dollars, checked within the last 30 days, but we have no accepted rating and no published expert test with a score for them, so the formula has nothing to rank them on. Each line gives the lowest price, the seller and the date checked.
57 creamy peanut butters
Show the 57 names
- Ambrosia Organic Farm Creamy Honey Peanut Butter - 250 gm / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $61.07 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Ambrosia Organic Farm Creamy Honey Peanut Butter - 250 gm / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet): $98.94 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- BEURRE 750g PEANUT CREAMY BIO (no separate page yet): $11.89 at Nature Sante, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Compliments Peanut Butter Spread (no separate page yet): $5.99 at Voilà by Sobeys, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $9.50 at Going Nuts, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Dazzley Creamy Jordnötssmör - Creamy Peanut Butter 350g (no separate page yet): $12.31 at sweetsbysvea.com, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Disano Chocolate Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $22.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Disano Classic Peanut Butter - 350 gm / Creamy / Pack of 1 (no separate page yet): $12.73 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Disano Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $23.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Disano Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $20.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Disano Peanut Butter Creamy 924g & DiSano Pure Honey 500 g (pack of 1) (no separate page yet): $15.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Dr. Oetker Fun Foods Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $2.49 at Gharstuff, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Farm Boy All Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Unsalted 500 g (no separate page yet): $4.99 at Voilà by Sobeys, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Fit Muscles Natural Peanut Butter Creamy Smooth - 850 gm / Pack of 1 (no separate page yet): $40.90 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Fit Muscles Natural Peanut Butter Creamy Smooth - 850 gm / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet): $191.27 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Haddar Creamy Peanut Butter,510 gm (no separate page yet): $6.57 at Never Wash A Dish, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Heeva Classic Creamy Peanut Butter 100% Roasted Peanuts 2kg (no separate page yet): $50.96 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Honey Peanut Butter 250g (no separate page yet): $12.50 at Habitude Design, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Jaggery Peanut Butter Creamy 1.05 kg (no separate page yet): $25.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Jif Creamy Peanut Butter Squeeze (no separate page yet): $3.97 at Giant Tiger, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Jif To Go Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $5.49 at Voilà by Sobeys, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Jiffy Peanut Butter Creamy Light (500 g) (no separate page yet): $6.41 at ubereats.com, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Jus Amazin Creamy Organic Peanut Butter – Sweet n Salty (200g X 2) (no separate page yet): $22.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Kirkland Signature Natural Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $17.99 at KJA Ventures, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- LifeSmart Life smart organic smooth Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $4.44 at foodbasics.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Manba classic creamy (no separate page yet): $7.49 at Dumornay Delis, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- ManiLife Original Roast Smooth Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $48.90 at GoSupps.com, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- MILLE ET UNE NOIX Organic Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $8.99 at Avril Supermarché Santé, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Mumgry Chocolate Peanut Butter 375g (no separate page yet): $12.99 at The Gourmet Warehouse, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Nana Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $5.99 at falconessentials.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Natural Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $7.99 at SPUD.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Natural Creamy Peanut Butter 35 Lbs, Bulk Nut Butter Distribution Canada (no separate page yet): $124.99 at Bulk Mart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Nuts to You Organic Smooth Peanut Butter + Salt (no separate page yet): $7.99 at Avril Supermarché Santé, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Only Goodness Organic No-Stir Smooth Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $7.99 at Save-On-Foods, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- OZiva Natural Peanut Butter-Creamy - 1 kg / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $83.98 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Pintola All Natural Peanut Butter Crunchy (no separate page yet): $42.34 at Pushmycart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Pintola Organic Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $10.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Pintola Organic Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg / Pack of 5 (no separate page yet): $281.95 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Puck creamy Cheese Spread (no separate page yet): $17.89 at Zum Zum, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Pureheart Nutbutter Creamy Peanut Butter - 350 gm / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $58.76 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread 18oz (no separate page yet): $11.30 at Candy District, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- REESES - CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER 510g REESES Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $48.90 at GoSupps.com, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- RICHNUT Chocolate Peanut Butter Spread – 100% Natural Turkish Peanuts & Rich Cocoa Creamy Protein Energy Spread 1Kg (no separate page yet): $26.00 at Bturkish, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- RiteBite Max Protein Classic Creamy Peanut Butter - 1 kg / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $93.54 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- RiteBite Max Protein Classic Creamy Peanut Butter - 340 gm / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $34.00 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Selection Extra Creamy Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $4.44 at foodbasics.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Skippy Creamy Smooth Peanut Butter Spread 340g (no separate page yet): $9.81 at McGrocer, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Skippy Smooth Peanut Butter Spread 340g (no separate page yet): $9.79 at McGrocer, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Smooth peanut butter (no separate page yet): $4.49 at superc.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Sundrop Peanut Butter | Creamy | 462 grams (no separate page yet): $11.99 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Toprak Doğal Osmaniye Peanut Butter – Creamy Natural Peanut Spread with Rich Nutty Flavor, Gluten-Free - 220g (no separate page yet): $18.00 at Bturkish, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Trader Joe's Creamy Peanut Butter, Salted, 454g (no separate page yet): $6.89 at konnichiwa.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Trader Joe's Creamy Unsalted Peanut Butter (no separate page yet): $6.89 at konnichiwa.ca, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Truefarm Organic Peanut Butter Creamy-Unsweetened - 500 gm / Pack of 3 (no separate page yet): $44.56 at Distacart, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Tuğba Kuruyemiş Creamy Peanut Butter Smooth & Spreadable – Natural Roasted Peanuts Rich Protein Nut Butter for Breakfast & Healthy Snacks (650g) (no separate page yet): $27.00 at Bturkish, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Veeba Creamy Peanut Butter| High Protein (no separate page yet): $21.49 at Silkrute, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
- Western Family - Smooth Peanut Butter - Light (no separate page yet): $4.69 at Save-On-Foods, in stock when checked on ; no rating or published test on record
Not ranked: offer check lapsed
These have no in-stock offer checked within the last 30 days. Older prices are not published.
40 creamy peanut butters
Show the 40 names
- Alpino Chocolate Peanut Butter Smooth Roasted Peanuts Chocolate Paste & Brown Sugar: offer never checked
- Alpino Classic Peanut Butter Crunch 90% Roasted Peanuts: offer never checked
- Big Spoon Roasters Maple Cinnamon Peanut & Pecan Butter with Sea Salt3 70g: offer never checked
- Big Spoon Roasters Sweet Heat Peanut Butter w/Habanero Chiles & Sea Salt: offer never checked
- Chef's Quality Creamy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Club supreme Creamy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Club Supreme Smooth & Creamy Peanut Butter Spread: offer never checked
- Fatso Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Great Value Crunchy Natural Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Great Value Crunchy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Great Value Light Smooth Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Great Value Natural Smooth Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Great Value Smooth Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Jif Creamy Light Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Jif creamy peanut Butter 1 kg Smooth no-stir creamy spread with that fresh-roasted peanut taste. Perfect for sandwiches: offer never checked
- Jif Creamy Peanut Butter GRR22000535: offer never checked
- Jif Creamy Peanut Butter Portion: offer never checked
- Jif Light Peanut Butter s smooth, it's creamy. it's Light. No-stir creamy spread perfect for toast: offer never checked
- Jif Peanut Butter Spread & Honey: offer never checked
- Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter 2 Pack | 28 Ounce Each Jar | U.S. Peanuts | 0644220035574 | Pantry: offer never checked
- Kraft All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Kraft Extra Roasted Flavour Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Kraft Extra Roasted Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Kraft Only Peanuts All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter, 750g (Pack of 12): offer never checked
- Laura Scudder's Old Fashioned Smooth Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces, All Natural: offer never checked
- Meridian Foods Peanut Butter Smooth with Salt: offer never checked
- Once Again Organic Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Peter Pan Peanut Butter Creamy: offer never checked
- REESE'S Smooth Traditional Peanut Butter Spread: offer never checked
- Simply Smooth Peanut Butter 16oz Non Gmo Vegan Gluten Free Creamy: offer never checked
- Skippy Classic Peanut Butter Spread Creamy Kosher 462g: offer never checked
- SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, 48 Oz., 2 Pk.: offer never checked
- Smucker's Creamy Natural Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Trader Joe's Creamy Salted Peanut Butter 16 Ounce Pack Of 1 Natural: offer never checked
- Trader Joe's Organic Creamy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter: offer never checked
- Yogti Peanut Butter Powder – Classic Plant Based Protein from Roasted Peanuts: offer never checked
- Yupik Natural Peanut Butter 454 g Kosher Gluten-Free GMO-Free: offer never checked
- Yupik Organic Peanut Butter: offer never checked